Sleep science

White vs Brown vs Pink Noise: Which Is Best for Sleep?

White, pink and brown noise are the same idea, a steady wash of sound, with different amounts of bass and treble. No color has been shown to be best for sleep. Steady noise mainly helps by covering sudden sounds, so choose the one you find most pleasant and play it quietly.

Key takeaways

  • White noise is a bright hiss, pink is softer and more even, brown is a deep rumble.
  • No color has been shown to be better for sleep, so pick the one you find pleasant.
  • Steady noise helps most when it masks sudden sounds such as traffic, neighbors or snoring.
  • The research is mixed and of low quality, so test it on yourself.
  • Keep the volume low and the speaker away from your head.

What do the noise colors mean?

The names are a loose borrowing from light. White light contains all the visible colors at once, and white noise contains all the audible pitches at equal strength. Pink and brown noise contain the same pitches but tilt the balance toward the low end.

White noise sounds like radio static or a hissing fan. Most of its energy sits in the higher pitches, which our ears pick up readily, so it can come across as bright or even harsh.

Pink noise turns the high pitches down steadily, so that each octave carries the same energy. The result is fuller and softer, like steady rain.

Brown noise drops off more steeply still, leaving mostly a low rumble, like a distant waterfall or the inside of an airplane cabin. The name has nothing to do with the color. It comes from Brownian motion, the random movement that the signal resembles.

ColorSounds likeOften preferred for
WhiteStatic, a hiss, a small fanCovering sharper sounds such as voices or a television through the wall
PinkSteady rain, wind in leavesAn all-round choice when white feels too sharp
BrownDistant waterfall, low rumble, airplane cabinCovering low sounds such as traffic rumble; people who like a deep, soft sound

Does noise really help you sleep?

There is some support. In one small lab study, healthy adults went through a simulated noisy, disrupted night, and with steady broadband noise playing they fell asleep about 38% faster.1 That is an encouraging result, but from a specific setup: good sleepers, a laboratory and a deliberately disturbed night.

The wider picture is less tidy. A systematic review of 38 studies judged the quality of the evidence that continuous noise improves sleep to be very low, with mixed results, and noted that loud noise could carry risks.2 In plain terms the question is still open: steady noise seems to help some people in some situations, and research cannot yet say how much or for whom.

Nor does the research single out a color. You will come across confident claims that pink or brown noise deepens sleep or sharpens memory. Given how uncertain the basic question still is, treat those claims with caution and go by your own experience.

When is masking noise worth trying?

Noise works by masking. A door slamming in a silent room is a big jump in sound, and big jumps are what wake you. Against a steady background the same slam is a smaller change, so it is less likely to pull you out of sleep.

That makes it most useful when your surroundings are unpredictable. Typical cases include:

  • street noise such as traffic, sirens and late-night voices;
  • neighbors, thin walls or housemates on a different schedule;
  • a partner who snores or gets up earlier than you;
  • hotels and other unfamiliar rooms;
  • a room so quiet that every creak stands out.

If your bedroom is already quiet and you sleep well, there is no reason to add sound. If different schedules are the issue, there are also ways to wake up without waking your partner. And if what you are covering is loud snoring with pauses or gasping, masking it is not the whole answer; read about what causes snoring and when to get it checked.

How loud should it be, and is it safe?

Quieter than you think. The aim is to blur disturbances, not to drown them, so set the volume just high enough that the sounds bothering you fade into the background. Then try turning it down a notch.

  • Keep the speaker away from your head. Across the room is better than on the pillow or the nightstand.
  • Be careful with earbuds. They put the sound right at your ear for hours, can be uncomfortable for side sleepers and may stop you from hearing a smoke alarm or your morning alarm.
  • Use a timer or fade-out if you only need help falling asleep, so that your ears get a quiet stretch.
  • Take extra care with babies and children. Keep the device well away from the crib, keep the volume low and ask your pediatrician if you are unsure.

The review mentioned above flagged possible risks from loud noise, which is the main reason to keep the level modest.2 If you are using noise to cover ringing in your ears, mention the ringing to a doctor, especially if it is new or only on one side.

How to choose between white, pink and brown

Since the research cannot pick for you, run a simple test. Play each color for a minute at the same low volume and notice your reaction. One will usually feel irritating, one neutral and one pleasant, so start with the pleasant one.

Then match it to the problem. Deeper sounds such as brown noise tend to cover low rumbles like traffic and bass from next door, while brighter noise does more against voices and clatter. Pink sits between the two and is the usual compromise.

Give your choice several nights before judging it. Note roughly how long you took to fall asleep and how often you remember waking, and compare that with a few nights of silence. Natural sounds with a similar texture, such as steady rain, a waterfall or a fan, work the same way, and some people simply like them better.

When is noise not the right fix?

Masking treats a symptom. If you can reduce the noise at its source, with a draft seal on the door, heavier curtains or earplugs you find comfortable, that is often better than adding more sound.

Think about why your window is shut, too. Closing it against street noise keeps the room quiet but also keeps the air in, and stale air may affect sleep in its own right; here is what bedroom CO₂ does to your night.

Noise will not fix trouble falling asleep that has other roots, such as caffeine too late in the day, an irregular schedule or worry. If you have struggled to sleep most nights for weeks, talk to a doctor instead of searching for the perfect sound.

Where to start tonight

  1. Listen to white, pink and brown noise for a minute each and pick the one you like.
  2. Place the speaker across the room and set the lowest volume that takes the edge off outside sounds.
  3. Use a fade-out or timer if falling asleep is the issue, and let it run if early-morning noise wakes you.
  4. After a week, compare how you slept with your usual nights, and keep it only if it helps.

If the answer is no, you have lost nothing. A quiet room is a perfectly good way to sleep, and plenty of people do better without any added sound.

Frequently asked questions

Is brown noise better than white noise for sleeping?

Not according to any solid evidence. Brown noise is deeper, and many people find it more comfortable than the hiss of white noise, which is a good enough reason to choose it. But there is no good evidence that one color improves sleep more than another. Use whichever you can ignore most easily at a low volume.

Is it bad to sleep with white noise every night?

There is little long-term research either way. A systematic review of noise as a sleep aid noted that loud noise could carry risks, so the sensible approach is a low volume, a speaker placed across the room and a timer if you only need help falling asleep. Getting used to it is a habit, not a medical problem.

Should sleep noise play all night or turn off after I fall asleep?

It depends on what wakes you. If the trouble is falling asleep, a timer or automatic fade-out gives your ears quiet for the rest of the night. If you are woken by early traffic, neighbors or a snoring partner, playing it all night at a low level keeps the masking effect for the hours when you need it.

What does pink noise sound like?

Pink noise sounds like steady rain or wind through leaves: fuller and less sharp than white noise, without the heavy rumble of brown noise. It carries more of its energy in the lower pitches than white noise does, which is why many people describe it as balanced or natural. Try it at a low volume and compare it with the other two.

Sources

  1. Messineo L, et al. Broadband sound administration improves sleep onset latency in healthy subjects in a model of transient insomnia. Frontiers in Neurology, 2017. doi.org/10.3389/fneur.2017.00718
  2. Riedy SM, Smith MG, Rocha S, Basner M. Noise as a sleep aid: a systematic review. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 2021. doi.org/10.1016/j.smrv.2020.101385

This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. WakeUp 2day is not a medical device and does not diagnose, treat or prevent any condition. If you are worried about your sleep or your health, talk to a doctor.